25 March 2010

On Rights- Part One: On the Origin of Rights

There are, perhaps, no more dangerous words in the English language than these:

"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed. That whenever any form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or abolish it."

They are dangerous not in and of themselves--no words are--but for the responses they inspire. At their very best, they inspire us to shatter the shackles of tyranny, to assert our "rights" as autonomous human beings to govern ourselves and live as we choose. At their very worst, and often after throwing off the shackles of tyrants, they inspire us to a different kind of tyranny, that of the atomistic individual, to take our status as autonomous human beings as license for the unrestrained exercise of will. Both the triumph and the tragedy of this stem from the assertion that these rights derive from a Creator or, as Jefferson puts it elsewhere in the Declaration of Independence, "Nature and Nature's God."

The tension is never more evident, the line between triumph and tragedy never more blurred, than in discussions (debates? hissy-fits?) about the meaning of our Constitution and, especially, of the Bill of Rights. Take, for example, the protection of speech. The first Amendment states: "Congress shall make no law...abridging the freedom of speech." Congress, as the legislative power, can be read to stand for the entire government. Government, of course, is "We the People," the repository of sovereignty. If we are to take seriously that freedom of speech, as a right, is an endowment from "Nature and Nature's God," then government cannot restrict any speech.

It is a triumph when the speech government cannot prevent is criticism of itself; it is a tragedy when it cannot prevent speech acts that lead to harm, such as child pornography. So we (most of us) have accepted certain limitations--I may not photograph children for prurient purposes, may not shout "Fire!" in a crowded theater. We accept these restrictions because accepting them is better than the alternative, but it is inescapable that in this acceptance we have begun to alienate our supposedly unalienable rights. Is it possible that these rights are not so self-evident as we have been led to believe?

Addressing this question requires us to step away for a moment from the language in which rights are expressed. If we accept that rights derive from a creator, we arrive at an impasse. Necessity requires us to accept them uncritically and to write off our failure to properly perceive and exercise our rights to the fallibility of human free will. The fact that we cannot be permitted full exercise of our "God-given" right to free speech is because fallen men exercise these rights in ways that are unconscionably harmful.

The truth is that we seldom think of the exceptions because most of us will never run up against the limitations they impose. We are then able to blithely ignore the contradiction inherent in the voluntary alienation of rights that, by the accepted definition, can not only not be taken away by government, but can also not be given away by us. This is a clumsy way of putting it, but a necessary one, since the expression of rights is largely a negative one. When we do think of the exceptions, and become alarmed, it is generally because someone in power is trying to force us to do something we don't want to do--this ability is, of course, the very definition of power. For speech restrictions, it could be attempts to place legal penalty on certain speech acts. However, we may also become alarmed at any legislation that is viewed as an infringement on the rights of an autonomous individual.

Yet, and this is where we must step back, taking the language of the Constitution seriously, "We the People" are sovereign; "We the People" are the government. We are also the guarantors of our rights and, we might argue, "We the People" are the source of those rights, if not originally, then at least inasmuch as "Nature and Nature's God" are nowhere to be found enforcing them. How else to explain the absence of divinity in the Constitution? How else to explain the evident discomfort of certain of the framers concerning the very inclusion of a Bill of Rights? The tacit admission of their inclusion is that the "God-given" rights might be infringed is an open admission that they can be infringed and that they are somewhat less than divine.

Does such an admission diminish the importance of these rights? No. It increases their importance. For if we are to accept that these rights do not derive from a creator, then we must accept responsibility for the exercise and, yes, limitation of these rights when appropriate. Limitations not only for others, whose exercise of rights we might disagree with, but for ourselves. And we must do this based on justice and with an eye toward the greater good. Which is more important, personal liberty or the greater good? I don't know. Embracing personal liberty at the expense of the greater good is either a praiseworthy embrace of principle or a shameful embrace of selfishness depending on circumstances. Embracing the greater good exposes us to danger of the elevation of society over the individual, and we know what tragedies can obtain from that. Is it not equally tragic to condemn society to the tyranny of the individual?

05 March 2010

The Boy in the Bubble

It was a slow day
And the sun was beating
On the soldiers by the side of the road.
There was a bright light
A shattering of shopwindows
The bomb in the baby carriage
Was wired to the radio.

For a song that starts with what seems to be a terrorist attack, Paul Simon's "Boy in the Bubble" is surprisingly upbeat. It's mostly the accordion, but also the up-tempo beat that kicks in. The way Simon sings it, especially at the end of each verse where he implores the listener "Don't cry baby, don't cry" is reassuring. He's getting by and so can we. By the time he gets to the third verse, the evocation of the terror of "the days of miracle and wonder" gives way to the hope of magic and healing in the explosively alliterative exhortation to "think of the boy in the bubble and the baby with the baboon heart."

Peter Gabriel's rendition of the song on his new album Scratch My Back goes in the opposite direction. The rhythm is the same, but Gabriel's version is decidedly down-tempo. His gravelly voice eschews the highs he is capable of, a counterpoint to Simon. The accompaniment is on piano and strings, so the typical trappings of pop are nowhere to be found. As a result, the melancholy that was perhaps latent waiting to be expressed is brought to the fore, the miracle and wonder called into question.

All of which is to say that the cover should be counted among the best of covers. Most of the time a cover is the same song with a different voice, as though the artist is afraid to explore the possibilities inherent in the tune. Perhaps this is the case and perhaps it is wise to be afraid. But for those who aren't there is the potential to make the old seem new. Only the best of covers can make you hear the old song in a new way; this is one of those.

14 January 2010

The Host Desecration Project 2: Thinking about the Latin

The hardest skill to develop in the course of becoming some sort of medieval scholar has been a facility with Latin. Before embarking on this journey in 2007, the last time I had studied Latin in any systematic way was in 1988, when I took a semester of it in eleventh grade. At various times since, I had undertaken a small study of the language and had managed to learn a bit about how it works. But this kind of knowledge and actually working with the language are two different things.

One could go on and on about Latin grammar and morphology- and for someone used to English, it is a bear- but for me the hardest thing about Latin is its lack of word order. There are few rules that dictate where a word, say the subject, needs to appear in the sentence. Meaning is determined by the morphology of the word, which means any word can be pretty much anywhere. Inflection is everything.

And while we're on the topic of sentences, there is also the problem that for most of the time Latin was in any kind of common use there were no sentences per se. Punctuation didn't come into vogue until the 13th or 14th century, and before the seventh or eighth there were commonly no spaces in written texts. Which means that Latin "sentences," as we understand sentences, are the creation of later editors.

Fortunately, I am working from an edited text which can be found here and here. As you can see, some kind editor has inserted punctuation, in an attempt to make it readable to "modern" readers. Of course, some of the sentences the editor has created are extremely long, again owing to the exigencies of Latin grammar.

Usually when I approach something like this, I am not necessarily interested in a full translation. I just want to know what's going on in the text and I may need to translate a portion of it at some point for quotes, in which case I need to be as faithful to the text as possible. For this project, though, I need to get across what the author of the text was trying to get across, which requires, I think, something different.

Since no one has really shown me how to do this, I have tried to work out my own approach for this project. The first thing I do is try to sort out the grammar explicitly on the page. I do this by rearranging the original Latin into something resembling modern English syntax. This does not work 100 percent, since there are often implied subjects and prepositions tied into the noun forms. Don't even get me started on participles. Still, I find that if I bracket in these implied pieces and make little notes as I go along, it works out well. I'll show more of this process in later posts, but here is an example using the first sentence.

As rendered by the editor:
"Magna quidem fuerunt beneficia quae populo suo Deus olim contulit, sed immensa sunt quae nobis Christianis divina largitas exhibuit, et in dies exhibet."
Leaving aside the meaning for the moment, I have found it convenient to break this into two sentences, rendered as follows:
"Beneficia quae Deus contulit populo suo olim fuerunt magna quidem. Sed quae divina largitas exhibuit, et in dies exhibet, nobis Christianis sunt immensa."
While this still renders an odd-sounding sentence in English, it becomes easier for me to deal with using my patchwork of Latin skills, leading to this:
"The benefits which God conferred on his people a long time ago were impressive. But those which divine largess showed, and in these days shows, to us Christians are immeasurable."
Once I'm at this point, I need to clarify what's happening here. Since this is an account of Host desecration, it seems obvious that "suo populo" refers to the Jews. I haven't decided how to handle that in the final translation as "his people" seems important theologically- it shows the then prevalent notion that the Christians superseded the Jews as the objects of God's affection. I'll probably put in a footnote.

Next: The Host Desecration Project 3: De Miraculo Hostiae: The Saga Begins

29 December 2009

The Host Desecration Project 1: Introduction

I am currently working on a little translation project to be published in a source reader my adviser is putting together. In the course of a paper I was working on a couple of years ago, I learned of an account of a Host desecration in the Recueil des historiens des Gaules et de la France. It is the first fully-articulated account of such an event. This is the story in brief:

On Easter day in 1290 a woman, who had pawned her clothes with a Jewish merchant, came to reclaim them. The merchant offered to return them free of charge if she would steal a consecrated Host from a Church. She did this, whereupon the Jew set about the business of tormenting the host in a recreation of the Passion, stabbing it, setting upon it with hammer and nails, and throwing it into a fire. None of this caused the least damage. Indeed, when thrown into the fire, the Host emerged whole and flew about the room. Once recaptured, the merchant threw it into a cauldron of boiling water, which then turned to blood and from which an apparition of the Christ child emerged. The tale continues with the discovery of this perfidy, the subsequent killing of the Jew and the woman, the conversion of his wife and children to Christianity, and the removal of the relics involved in this to various churches.

This story emerged at the end of the 13th century, when the doctrine of transubstantiation was firmly and finally entrenched. Written into church law with the canons of the Fourth Lateran Council in 1215, it became the only tolerated position on the Eucharist by the end of the thirteenth century, given special impetus by the work of Thomas Aquinas in the 1270s. This meant that, in Catholic doctrine, one was required to believe that beneath the appearances (accidents) of the bread and wine of the sacrament was to be found the true, historical, body of Christ. Each time a Christian took the Eucharist, then, he or she was enaging in theophagy and anthrophagy. A less kind way of putting it would be cannibalism, and I suspect that stories like this one reflect the lingering anxieties felt by theologians about the sacrament on this very matter.

The account I am working on has never been translated- or at least published- in English. I thought it would be fun to write a little about this project and about the process I use for the translation as I struggle to come to grips with Latin, as well as sharing the translation in progress.

Next: Thinking About the Latin.

10 December 2009

The Medieval Church

I will be teaching a five-session class on the Medieval Church at St. Michael's Episcopal Church in Raleigh across five Sundays in Lent 2010. This is exciting, as I think it is the obligation of professional (or semi-professional, as the case may be) historians to reach out to the wider public. I hope to get back in to doing this blog and think I'll post materials relating to preparation for the class as I go forward. For now all I have is the class description and a biography to be published in their catalog. There's also a mug shot, which I will not post here.

The Medieval Church:The so-called Medieval Church defies easy description. Spanning roughly a thousand years, it is perhaps best thought of as a succession of "medieval churches," each with its own character but very much rooted in what came before. This class is an introduction to those medieval churches, exploring the paths taken by "the Church" as it faced the challenges wrought upon Western Europe by barbarian invasion, the growth of empires and their dissolution, conflicts with kings, heresy, and the changed intellectual landscape of the high and late Middle Ages. These challenges shaped the institution of the Church, even as it attempted to shape disparate European cultures into a single entity--Christendom. The results reverberate even today.

16 August 2009

Donald Westlake's "Parker: the Hunter" by Darwyn Cooke

Make no mistake about it, Parker is not a good guy. He is a criminal who has been double crossed by his partner and by the woman he loves. "Parker: The Hunter," Darwyn Cooke's graphic adaptation of the first novel in Donald Weslake's series about Parker, is a smashing introduction to this character. The classic setup, a betrayed man seeking vengeance, does nothing to diminish the freshness of the character and of Cooke's approach to him.

Cooke, familiar to comics readers as the writer/ artist of "Catwoman: Selina's Big Score," "The Spirit" and, especially, "DC: The New Frontier," is perfectly suited to this tale. His drawings easily evoke the early 1960s, and the monochromatic palette is perfectly suited to the story.

"The Hunter" is dark, briskly-paced, and told with economy, as a good noir novel should be, and Cooke presents it with panache. As in the Mel Gibson movie "Payback," which was based on this book, we pull for the bad guy because, as bad as he is, he's better than those he fights.

I generally steer clear of graphic adaptations of prose works. It seems to me that they always lack a certain something that made the original work. I have not (yet) read the original novel, but I am left with the sense that, in Cooke's hands, the essence of the novel has been captured. It is telling that this is the first adaptation of a Westlake work that has been allowed to carry the Parker name.

Cooke says Parker will return in summer 2010. I'll be waiting.

"Men and Cartoons" by Jonathan Lethem

Jonathan Lethem is one of the most distinctive and inventive writers of fiction today. From "Gun with Occasional Music" to "You Don't Love Me Yet," Lethem has shown an uncanny ability to transport readers into a world that, upon reflection, is incredibly strange but at the same time feels right.

"Men and Cartoons," Lethem's second collection of short stories, shows the (many) strengths of his writing, but also the danger in letting his fertile imagination run wild. The nine stories in the book are all beautifully written if uneven.

"The Vision" and "Vivian Relf" show the wistful evocation of earlier times that Lethem used to great effect in his latest, and best known works, "Motherless Brooklyn" and "Fortress of Solitude," as he evokes the follies and foibles of youth and how they hang on into adulthood. Along with "Super Goat Man," there is the powerful undercurrent of regret and nostalgia that haunts his best work.

"The Spray" and "Access Fantasy" tap the same veins, but show the powerful science fiction imagination that fueled Lethem's earlier work and were showed to great effect in his short story collection "The Wall of Sky, the Wall of Eye." The latter story also shows the potential weakness of being so inventive- wonderful ideas not fully realized. Perhaps we are meant to take the existence of the One-Way Permeable Barrier for granted, but a little more on it might have helped the story hang together better.

"The Dystopianist" is an interesting vignette of what might happen were a writer to be visited, even briefly, by his creations. The stark realism with which the story is written stands in relief to the absurdity and surrealism of the story. Other stories in the book, though well-written, failed to leave much impression.

Taken as a whole, "Men and Cartoons" is a wonderful collection of stories by a masterful writer. Readers who have never read Lethem can get a sample of the variety of styles he uses, while old readers can get a Lethem fix.

15 August 2009

Philosophy and Death

"I have seen the moment of my greatness flicker
And I have seen the eternal Footman hold my coat, and snicker,
And in short, I was afraid."
-- T.S. Eliot

Death haunts me, as it does most of us. Being dead is not a worry. I expect no afterlife, no metempsychosis; death is the obliteration of self. Once I have died, there will be no "me" to register the fact of my demise. Still, there is the final moment, the terminal point where one ceases to be a subject and becomes an object. This is the aspect that frightens me. I cannot- none of us can- imagine non-existence.

Simon Critchley begins his work, "The Book of Dead Philosophers" from this point. Accepting Cicero's dictum that "to philosophize is to learn how to die," Critchley writes of how 190 philosophers spoke about and faced death. His aim is to counter the facile attempts in this modern age to deny the fact of death through "the transitory consolation of momentary oblivion or a miraculous redemption in the afterlife."

It is important to note, especially in the face of a potentially incendiary quote like the one above, that his is not a flat-out denial of an afterlife. His point is that all we can know is that we are living and that, by denying death through consumption or religion, we truncate our lives. Accepting death is the only way to truly live.

So we learn how philosophers faced death. Socrates' argument that death, be it eternal sleep or the reunion with the honored dead, is not to be feared is the logical starting point. Then, following a rough chronology, we encounter the early materialists who preceded Socrates, the Platonists, Epicureans and Stoics who came after him, Romans, Chinese. The common thread is that death is something that cannot be overcome, so it is not to be feared.

There are even entries for members of an obscure group of Jews following a teacher from Galilee. These are perhaps the most interesting in some ways. Those who know only the flavors of Christianity available today forget that, at its base, the faith is all about death. Chritchley accuses most modern Christians of "actually leading quietly desperate atheist lives bounded by a desire for longevity and the terror of annihilation." The central preoccupation of Paul, for instance, is death. It is Paul who tells us how Adam brought death and how Jesus, through his own death, conquered death. St. Anthony pursued his faith by becoming dead to the world, founding Christian monasticism in the process.

I did not intend to dwell on Christianity, but since its presence is so strongly felt, it creates a gravity of its own. The point is that, excepting beliefs in an afterlife, the way someone like Paul faced death was not so different from the way someone like Hume did. The cheerfulness Hume is reported to have shown as he died is akin to the joy expressed in martyrdom accounts. Both show, for different reasons, an acceptance of the fact of death and an understanding that it cannot be avoided.

This is a wonderful book. Chritchley's prose is lively and humorous; there is something of the smart-aleck about him. His argument that we should embrace death as part of life and not dwell morosely on it is bolstered by his presentation. Critchley has me thinking about death differently. Perhaps, instead of pursuing my true love of History, I should have dallied longer with my mistress Philosophy. The consolations (see Boethius) to be found there are more than religion could ever offer me.

"Whatever Happened to the Caped Crusader" by Neil Gaiman

It seems so long ago that I really liked the work of Neil Gaiman. Like many, I was enthralled by "Sandman" and roundly entertained by "Good Omens." Then came "Neverwhere" and "American Gods," reusing many of the tricks and tropes from his earlier work and I began to doubt his powers. "Whatever Happened to the Caped Crusader" has done little to dispel my doubts.

Gaiman writes the story of many deaths of Batman, described by those who knew him best: the villains and allies in his 70-year fight against crime. Two ghostly presences (one of whom is, no surprise, Bruce Wayne) watch and comment on the proceedings. Bruce protests at the beginning that these things didn't happen, but the other presence counsels him to listen.

This is the problem. The other presence might as well have been Death of the Endless, or Dream. One can almost hear Dream telling Queen Mab that a story need not have happened for it to be true. Get a new trick, Neil.

Since this story marks a transition to a new Batman (Bruce Wayne died, or not, in the pages of "Final Crisis") the logical comparison, one which Gaiman alludes to in his introduction, is Alan Moore's wonderful "Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow," which provided a breaking point between the god-like Superman of the 70s and early 80s and John Byrne's re-imagining of the Man of Steel's origins. I re-read the earlier work for this review, and it holds up well, though Moore is a better writer today than he was then.

Moore understands Superman better, I think, than Gaiman understands Batman (I also think Moore gets Batman, but that's not for now). Superman and Clark Kent are coterminous in a way that Bruce Wayne and Batman are not, a point borne out by the fact that Batman endures after the death of Bruce Wayne. Other writers, less talented than Gaiman, have understood this as well.

I have been dwelling so long on the failings of Gaiman that I have said not a word about Andy Kubert's art. The word is WOW! The art is amazing, evocative of the decades of legendary Batman artists like Bob Kane, Neal Adams and Brian Bolland. It makes the book worth reading.

This book has garnered a great deal of acclaim for both Gaiman and Kubert, not least from the New York Times, and one suspects it is a lock for Eisner awards next year. Gaiman will get the same free pass given to writers like Grant Morrison. Doubtless I am on the losing side of this argument, but someone has to speak up. "Whatever Happened to the Caped Crusader" is a serviceable story, but one that is not up to his talents and one not suited to the task.

12 August 2009

"Mouse Guard: Winter, 1152" by David Petersen

When we last saw the stalwarts of the Mouse Guard, they were facing a cold, hard winter in the aftermath of betrayal by one of their number. In volume one of the series, Fall 1152, David Petersen introduced us to Leiam, Kenzie, Saxon and Sadie of the Guard, their leader Gwendolyn, the mysterious guard known as the Black Axe, and the town of Lockhaven. The Guard is charged with protecting the routes between the mouse towns and with fighting threats against mousekind. The wonderful art (also by Petersen) combined with a rip-roaring action tale to produce one of the most purely fun graphic books I've read in ages.

Petersen does not miss a beat in volume two, Winter 1152. The Guard, charged with requesting supplies from other towns so Lockhaven can last the winter, is scattered across the icy landscape. There they face all manner of threats and through these, bits of mouse history are revealed. Petersen succeeds in immersing the reader in the world of the Guard, creating bizarre and beautiful worlds. This is the kind of thing graphic media does best.

Who lives? Who dies? What is the nature of the new threat facing Lockhaven? I don't wish to give anything away, suffice it to say that nothing is a throwaway, and the consequences of past actions seem likely to linger into the future. While there are some things that seem predictable about this series, there is much that is surprising as well. Petersen's imagination and improving (!) artwork make this worth a read. One can only hope that Spring, 1153 is on the way.

01 July 2009

Darwin and Clio- A Persepective on History and Religion

When I look at the middle ages, I see myself reflected back. This is the justification I most often give when asked why I have chosen to focus, as a historian, on the time period stretching roughly from fifth century to the fifteenth. It is, as Morris Bishop put it, a period of continuation and transition. There is a continuation from the Roman and Germanic precedents, and a transition in social organizations that continues to the present.

When I ponder the study of history as a whole, I tend to think of fossils, representing the ancestry of the present. In more concrete terms, I think of hominid fossils, and it is during this period that the fossils begin to resemble the present. It is something akin to holding the skull of Homo sapiens at the moment he emerged from Africa and thinking: this is us.

The practice of history requires more than knowledge of dates and names. It is the study of cultures as much as events. Questions of who and when and when are important, but answering them is not sufficient to practice the historian’s craft; one must endeavor to understand the why, even though the why is seldom fully understood. This is perhaps the greatest misconception of history among the wider public, that everything in history is cut and dried. Each historian brings to the practice his own diagnostic tools with which he approaches the evidence, and these tools influence the final result. Among the lenses through which I view history is Darwinian evolution, for the value it has in the consideration of culture. All too often, culture is treated as something completely chosen. But Darwin tells us something different, and we need to consider this as well when we study anything people do.

Darwin realized that when he applied his theory of evolution by natural selection to humans, this would open all facets of human existence to examination by the light of biology. He argued that through selection, humans had acquired an ability to imitate, to pay attention, to imagine and to reason. Yet his fundamental insight, and one we must consider, is that humans are, at bottom, no different from other animals. That, though we have the vocal capacity to claim our superiority and the technological ability to enforce it, we are subject to the same drives and risks, ultimately, as every other organism. Indeed, it is nature that has brought us to this point. The marvel of this is overlooked; it is as seminal to an honest view of ourselves as Galileo’s joining of the heavens and the Earth by one set of rules was to an honest view of the universe.

Culture, then, must be seen as an outgrowth of biology as well and as subject to the same selection pressures as biology. The most important reason that humans do the things they do is because those things have, in the past, contributed to greater reproductive success than doing other things. So, as a historian looks at the human past, it would serve him well when he sees some strange cultural artifact, to remember that at some point it was adaptive. This must include the origins of religion.

Darwin understood man not to have been “aboriginally endowed with the ennobling belief in an omnipotent God” and thus sought to place the origins of religion in the struggle for existence.[1] In the pages that followed, Darwin proposed that there was a belief in “unseen spiritual agencies” that was common among the less civilized peoples of the world and, though to the skeptic this may appear to be a distinction without a difference, posited that such could “easily pass into the belief in the existence of one or more gods.”[2]

There can be little doubt that religion is ultimately a social phenomenon, whether one believes it an adaptation to social living or a gift from the deity to guide a certain group. Darwin saw morality as an adaptation to social living, since “[n]o tribe could hold together if murder, robbery, treachery, & c., were common; consequently such crimes within the tribe are ‘branded with everlasting infamy.’” [3] He made this statement in the context of an argument about sympathy, which he believed allowed people to be social, and suggested that the lack of morality evinced among uncivilized tribes was due to their lack of sympathy for those outside the tribal group. As forward-thinking as Darwin was, he was still at times hobbled by ingrained prejudices. Cultural mechanisms such as religion, it has been argued, are necessary to regulate behavior in groups that are too large for each member to know each other member. Religion, then, must arise as one of those regulators of relations within tribal groups, and its prescriptions and proscriptions must be viewed in this light.

Historians tend to treat religion and culture as something entirely man-made or, if they are theistically-minded, as artifacts handed down from the heavens. Darwin, by contrast, requires us to look to our biology for at least a partial answer to the deeper “why” questions we pursue. Thinking in this way allows the historian to view historical phenomena in a different light. We can see culture rising by selection, performing a selective function and fading when it is no longer adaptive.

This, then, is the perspective that Darwinian thought offers to the historian. It is a further tool to investigate the why questions that are left over once who, when and where have been answered. If we, as historians, begin with the notion that people are, to some extent, driven by their biology, then we can see the things people do as answers to the question of how best to survive long enough to pass our genes to our offspring. We can understand that, at some point in the distant past, our individual chances of survival were enhanced by banding together and sharing resources and responsibility. The dark side of this is that our survival was also enhanced by treating members of other groups, attempting to do the same thing we were, as somehow fundamentally different and applying different rules to them, removing the protections we give to members of our own group. This can be used in considering broad issues such as heresy and orthodoxy, or in particular religious ideas, such as the prohibition on usury in the Abrahamic faiths.

Such a view also helps us understand why certain cultural appendages continue long after their usefulness has passed. At some point in the past, each piece of the culture we inherited from our parents provided, if not a distinct advantage in the struggle for existence, at least no detriment. This is a strong incentive to continue practices that might seem logically outmoded or even detrimental to ourselves and others. As long as a certain beliefs or modes of living are not an obstacle to reproductive success, they will likely endure and be passed on to offspring, not through genetics, but through imitation and instruction.

But it also provides no excuse. When we can see, in the light of selection, that a practice once beneficial has become detrimental, then by all rights we should alter it. We should recognize the reasons we persist in it and, using the autonomy selection has granted us, break free. And in this sense, a view of history that takes this into account could potentially be prescriptive. If history is to speak to us, after all, it is because the story it tells is our story, the lessons learned bear upon our present and our future. Why bother with it, with anything, otherwise?

[1] Charles Darwin, The Descent of Man in E.O. Wilson, ed., From so Simple a Beginning: The Four Great Books of Charles Darwin (New York: W.W. Norton and Company, 2006), 814.

[2] Ibid., 815.

[3] Ibid., 830.

28 June 2009

"Magnificent Desolation" by Buzz Aldrin

Buzz Aldrin's latest memoir, "Magnificent Desolation: The Long Journey Home from the Moon" holds nothing back as Aldrin reveals his struggles with depression and alcoholism following his voyage to the moon. Indeed, the events of July 20, 1969 occupy only about 20 percent of the book, the rest dealing with the inevitable letdown that followed the Apollo 11 mission. This book is honest and, though not as well-written as his previous memoir "Men from Earth," authentic and, for the most part, humble.

This is not to say the book is without flaws. There are places where a little more editing could have been used. Aldrin's seeming disdain in some places for medication to treat depression might be seen as blase. There are times where the moral seems to be that all that is required for a man to beat depression is the love of a good woman. The final third of the book often seems to be promotion for SpaceShare, a non-profit venture to promote civilian space travel.

Still, it is hard to fault him in his zeal for space travel and exploration, and as a rallying cry for progress in these fields "Magnificent Desolation" is valuable. One can forgive the occasional lapses in his humility, such as when he refers to himself as "a visionary often stymied by a bureaucratic maze" (311) if only because he is one of twelve people ever to have set foot on another world. And any voice attempting to rouse us to the greater exploration of space should be considered.

"I believe," he concludes, "that mankind must explore or expire. We must venture outward" Amen.

The Auctioneer (part two of two)

Part one here...

A pod of people formed on both sides of the first pile. The auctioneer set his hand on the tobacco, as though blessing it before it was sent out into the world. He began by calling out the number of the pile and an opening price, raising it by watching the subtle gestures of the buyers who stood around the pile. Within 10 seconds the pile was sold, for $1.94 a pound and he had moved on to the next pile. As he moved, another man called out the final price while a third reached for the card, wrote something on it, and threw it back on the pile.

The auctioneer seemed to fall into a trance, nudging the price gently higher until each pile sold. I watched in awe as he proceeded from pile to pile down the row, never running out of breath, always in the same cadence, raising the assembly like a charismatic preacher with his subtle shifts of tone. When we reached the end of the first row, we performed a precise maneuver; the auctioneer turned to face the pile of tobacco behind him while the buyers, opposite and outside the aisle walked around, like the pencil on the end of a compass. It was then, as the yin and yang of the auction shifted that I understood.

There are no coincidences. One night, not long before, I had been channel surfing between the halves of a basketball game. I stopped on one of the specialty channels in the nether regions of cablespace, transfixed by the image of a Tibetan lama, robed in saffron chanting over a mandala. Relaxing into the steady rhythm of his prayer, I was unaware that my then-girlfriend had entered the room until she leaned over the back of the sofa, her hair falling over my shoulder. She kissed my cheek and said, “I wonder what he’s selling.” I looked at her and raised an eyebrow. She smiled the smile of seduction and said, “Sounds like he’s having an auction.”

I turned off the television.

* * *
As I stood outside the knot of people around the auctioneer, I realized what had brought me here. I knew then why I would spend my coming days wandering from small town to small town across America, attending, when I could, a tobacco auction here or a farm auction there, perhaps an estate up for the bidding or a parcel of land for commercial development, listening to the singsong of the auctioneer’s cant. And finally, upon reaching the sea, perhaps voyaging across it to India or Tibet to hear the other holy men chant their chant, offer their wares. From there, perhaps, to the infinity I had just glimpsed.

In that moment I understood what the auctioneer could not have understood about himself, that it was not tobacco or drug forfeitures or pop art that he auctioned, but attachment. The auctioneer’s twang sang out to me, to all of us, as the buyers assembled thought they purchased a farm commodity, but were actually accruing parts of the divine. And the auctioneer, oblivious to his role, an unknowing boddhisattva, the catalyst, continued. He was an old man, who had surely been doing this for quite some time, selling his self and with that loss of self gaining entrance to another plane. Perhaps he would be reincarnated as an auctioneer in a larger venue, perhaps at Sotheby’s or Christie’s where the speedy murmur would give way to more measured and aristocratic tones. Or perhaps that was bad karma; perhaps he had already been there and this was his reward.

Maybe, I thought, he’ll simply go to the top. Moving up, becoming a lama himself, an auctioneer of his own soul, bringing upward along the great chain of being those whose lives he touched as this man in North Carolina. Or was this his final stop, having acquired and then discarded sufficient divinity, having peered over the wall into the jeweled city but not crossing into it, coming back to tell us all the way, giving pieces of himself to serve as a compass? I pondered these questions, but dared not ask him for fear of breaking the spell. Instead, as I left the building and found my way to the road that would carry me to Tennessee, I could only content myself with images of his next life, auctioning his divinity to the most willing bidders.

26 June 2009

"Our Magnificent Bastard Tongue" by John McWhorter

This is an intriguing little book whose goal is to advance some interesting arguments about English, indeed a magnificent, bastard tongue. Unlike other books I have read on the topic, OMBT does not approach the history of English from the standpoint of vocabulary (though there is some at the end) but from the grammar. Specifically, he attempts to account for some of the quirks of English that are not easily accounted for by mainstream narratives of the development of the language.

English, in John McWhorter's view is a language spoken by Germans, heavily influences by Celtic-speakers, battered by Vikings and heir to a rich influence from Semitic languages.

He leads with his strongest argument: that, far from having a negligible influence limited to only a few words, the Celtic languages spoken at the time of the German invasions of England left their fingerprints everywhere. The most important evidence for this is the meaningless "do" (as in "Did you hear that Celtic languages exerted a lot of influence on English?) and the "ing" marker used to denote the present progressive. These features are not present in any Indo-European language, except for the Celtic languages.

From there he continues to show how Vikings ruling in England and speaking Northumbrian were instrumental in eliminating the case endings from the Germanic language of the English, leading to the simplified grammatical structure we have today. English is the least inflected language of the European languages, and it is because of these Viking influences.

Finally, and most controversially, he advances a notion that Proto-Germanic, the mother tongue of English and the other Germanic languages, was heavily influenced through contact with at least one of the Semitic languages, possibly Phoenecian. One-third of the vocabulary of Germanic languages is not easily traceable to the reconstructed Proto-Indo-European roots. Among these are words heavy in certain consonantal sounds and those which mark a change in tense by changing the vowel.

Along the way, McWhorter takes issue with the notion of "bad" grammar, scoring points against the whole notion in a way that makes this reviewer a little uncomfortable. He also effectively demolishes the notion that grammar is a wholesale representation of the way speakers of a language group think. The meat of the book is the three arguments above, and they are presented in the order of their strength beginning with the strongest and using the momentum to carry through the argument about Semitic influence. I am not enough of a linguist to evaluate them in terms of linguistics, but all seem worth considering.

Satisfying through and through, "Our Magnificent Bastard Tongue" is certainly worth reading. McWhorter approaches a subject that could easily be subsumed in dry technical jargon and presents it with humor throughout, while not straying from his argument. Anyone interested in the history of this wonderful, messed-up language we know and love should find much to enjoy here.

25 June 2009

Yorktown

A column by Jim Jenkins in this morning's News & Observer has me thinking about Yorktown and the importance of the place in my personal and (dare I say?) professional life. Not that this is the only time I have thought about Yorktown lately. In preparing my Master's thesis for North Carolina State University, I felt the need to pause and reflect upon those people who influenced me along in my continuing journey as a historian. The first of these was my father and it was through innumerable walks with him not only at Yorktown, but also at nearby Newport News Park, itself home to earthworks from the Civil War battle of Yorktown. Nearly every weekend, sometimes both days, for four or five years we visited these places, the walks ending on the precipice of puberty and the struggle for autonomy that begins then.

Those walks were my first history lesson, and one of the forces that led me to become a historian, albeit of medieval Europe. They also helped instill a love of country that endures despite constant disappointment with those in power of whatever party, as well as the respect and admiration for those soldiers and patriots who, for complicated and often contradictory reasons, fought for America's independence.

As the Fourth of July approaches it seems appropriate to think about this and just how fragile the seemingly solid edifice of history is. It would be easy to look back, see how things happened, and think that they could not have happened otherwise. But Yorktown offers a different lesson. The situation was precarious. Had the French fleet of Comte de Grasse not defeated the British fleet which had come to relieve Cornwallis, cutting off not only reinforcement, but also escape, the result could have been vastly different. Consideration of how close-fought this was, of how close-fought every pivotal moment is, should be a corrective against hubris, or claims of divine favor.

As I reach milestones on my personal journey as a historian, it is nice to pause and reconnect with those places that were important along the way. It is heartening to see that the place that touched my life so profoundly continues to touch the lives of others.