18 June 2009

Novel thoughts

So, I have been toying with the idea of a short novel based on the execution of heretics at Orleans in 1022, which was the center of my Master's thesis. The events of 28 December 1022 are described in five primary accounts, which differ in details, some significantly. The narrator is a monk named Heribert, who appears (sort of) in two of these accounts. He is, perhaps, the only one of the heretics to recant and be spared the flames, though one of the accounts mentions a monk and a nun recanting. In this short passage, the differences between two of the accounts begin to be explained. There is a dispute over which of the accounts is most reliable, and one's position on this matter tends to depend on whether one believes the heretics in France were home-grown or had been proselytized by Bogomil heretics from Bulgaria. The accounts, in chronological order:
  1. Jean of Ripol (early 1023): John was an eyewitness. His account is judged reliable by all, but is prized by those favoring a home-grown heresy. I judge him most reliable.
  2. Ademar of Chabannes (c. 1027): Ademar receieved information from a distance. His account is favored by those favoring Bogomil missionary activity on the strength of his identification of the heretics as "Manichaeans." Referred to in the text below as "that dolt from Limoges." I judge him least reliable, as his account lacks important detail and trades in tropes.
  3. Rodolphus Glaber (c. 1037): Ralph the Bald- "the bald monk"- may have learned some details of the heretics from the prosecuting bishop in the case. His placement varies most from author to author. I think he is the third most reliable witness to the account.
  4. Andre of Fleury (before 1042): Andre was also an eyewitness, who recorded his story in two works. "The Life of Gauzlin" tells the tale of his abbot, who participated in the synod that prosecuted the heretics. "The Miracles of Saint Benedict" tells of the blessings bestowed upon the monastery of Saint-Benoit sur Loire, his monastery. Andre may have witnessed the proceedings. I think he is about as reliable as John of Ripol.
  5. Paul of Saint-Pere de Chartres (c. 1075): Paul's account may have been based on the recollections of the nobleman Arefast who, according to this tale, infiltrated and exposed the group. Contains lurid details suggestive of dualist heresy. This account takes pride of place for those seeking Bogomil influence. I find it only slightly more reliable than Ademar.
The bald monk from Bèze who writes so feverishly has been studiously avoiding me. I have little desire to interact with him, but it seems inevitable. Caught up in the enthusiasm for the recently passed millennium of the Crucifixion, he writes in incomprehensible Latin of the events surrounding the year 1000 and of the so-called prodigies in the years immediately before and after. In love with his own words, he speaks of Gaul being covered in a mantle of white churches as the people turned to God with the turning of the years and with the expectation of the approaching end.

Among the prodigies he writes of is a peasant from Vertus, who thought he had been entered through the genitals by a swarm of bees and who entered the church, destroying the cross and spreading heresy before ultimately throwing himself in a well. In another piece, he writes of a scholar in Ravenna who, visited in a dream by demons disguised as Vergil, Juvenal and Horace, preached their works as Christians preach the Gospel. Reason argues against the truth of these stories, but I am told he actually believes them.


And indeed, some months after his arrival I am told by the abbot to speak to the bald monk, his name is Rodolphus, of my experiences at Orléans. He wants me to help this Rodolphus with his history, as I did that dolt from Limoges. When we finally meet, he claims to have met Odolric at Bèze, as the bishop returned from a pilgrimage to Jerusalem. This was likely enough, and I am interested to learn from him what Odolric has told him of our sect. If he learned anything from the bishop, it will consist of lies, either those I told Odolric or those he invented himself.


It was not hard to take the measure of this man. This was what one did as principal of the church school, especially when one had something to hide, and I evaded detection for nearly five years. He was not truly interested in what we believed; he said as much when he admitted to believing we practiced the same religion as some sectarians he had heard of from Italy. I encouraged this, expressing shock and admiration that he had realized that connection, one that none had made before. We had been taken in, I reluctantly informed him, by a woman from Italy who, diabolically possessed, spread the poison with her sex.


17 June 2009

"Beware Greeks Bearing News" Intro

I am in the process of making the final revisions to my paper for the International Medieval Congress, a process I call "polishing the turd." Here is the introduction. This is a bit more abrupt than I typically am as a writer, but I only have twenty minutes to read this, which means no more than ten pages.

Alarmed at the heretics plaguing Périgord in the early decades of the eleventh century, a monk styling himself Héribert sounded the warning to the four corners of the Earth.
To all Christians in the Orient and the Occident, North and South, who believe in Christ, Peace and Mercy in God the Father, in his only son our Lord and in the Holy Ghost.
Hard upon this rallying cry there followed an indictment of the heretics who exhibited extreme austerity, refusing meat and wine, and genuflecting a hundred times per day. They took no money and practiced communalism. Charity was not accepted, since they denied one ought to own property. Consisting of clerks, priests, monks and nuns, to all appearances they were a pious group.

But behind this façade lurked more sinister transgressions. According to Héribert they would not enter a church, except to recruit new members to their sect. At the end of the Pater Noster, instead of the usual “Glory to the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit,” the heretics said, “for yours is the kingdom, you are rule all creatures forever and ever, amen.” They denied the worth of the Mass. The chant used during the service was said “to be vain and invented for the favor of men.” When they did enter the church, always in the cause of seducing converts, they would not chant the canon or take communion. Two strategies were used to avoid taking communion: the heretics either skirted the altar or, if they were unable to turn away, spit the Host into the missal. The heretics also refused to adore the Cross and the crucified Lord. Those worshiping it were to be pitied, and were compared to the worshipers of idols in the book of Psalms.

Recent scholarship using the “Letter of Héribert” along with the sermons of Adémar of Chabannes has done much to revive the notion that the heretics of eleventh-century France were proselytized by Bogomil missionaries from the Byzantine Empire. This scholarship has pointed toward superficial similarities between the western heretics described and the dualist Bogomils, and toward the language used in polemics against the new religious movements as evidence of their connection. I intend to propose that these similarities cannot necessarily be taken as prima facie evidence of such a connection. They may, rather, constitute evidence of a different kind of influence—that of visiting Orthodox monks on the reporting of dissident movements by their Catholic brethren, who saw superficial similarities between the very real threat of Bogomilism in the East and the nascent reformist movements which sought a return to the life of the primitive Church in the West.

04 June 2009

"A Terrible Splendor" by Marshall Jon Fisher

On a sweltering afternoon in July of 1937 the lives of three of the greatest tennis players of the 20s and 30s intersected on Center Court of Wimbledon in the final match of the Davis Cup semifinal, a match called by many, as the subtitle says, the greatest tennis match ever played. Don Budge, who had won the Championships on the same court a couple of weeks earlier, clinching the world number one ranking, played for the American squad in this decisive match. His opponent in this match was Baron Gottfried von Cramm, the world number two, whom Budge had easily dispatched in that Wimbledon final. In the stands was the greatest player in the history of the sport, Big Bill Tilden, who had been perennially snubbed by the American Lawn Tennis Association as a coach and who sought a measure of revenge by unofficially coaching Cramm.

The details of the match are well-known. Cramm, jumping out to a two-set lead, was defeated by a resurgent Budge, cementing the latter's position as the greatest player of the 30s. What is less well-known is how the storylines of these three players reflect so well the political stories of the time. Budge, the red-headed hope of American tennis, is playing for honor and glory. Cramm, a homosexual, is playing to keep the Gestapo at bay just a little bit longer. Tilden, also gay, is trying to stay in the game.

Fisher writes dynamically about the match and about the events in the lives of the players and the lives of all the world leading up to it. Even knowing the outcome, he manages to generate tension on the page. The reader is kept in the moment by the use of the present tense in match descriptions, shifting to the past for background. He skilfully breaks the background information down and interweaves it around breathless descriptions of pivotal moments in the game. The result is a book of nonfiction that reads like a novel.

Despite a typo here and there, "A Terrible Splendor" is a remarkable book. For the tennis fan, there is a glimpse into the state of the sport before the Open era, when the lines between amateur and professional were sharply delineated. For the history buff, there is a look into the intersection of sports and politics, especially in the Third Reich. This has been done before, but most commonly around the 1936 Olympics and the Schmelling/ Louis boxing matches. Finally, for the general reader of nonfiction, there is a riveting story well-told. "A Terrible Splendor" is the best sports book I have ever read, and certainly among the best nonfiction I have read this year.

27 March 2009

Heresy as Historical Fiction?

A strong gust penetrates the window coverings, stirring loose sheets of vellum and causing my candles to flicker, bringing with it small snowflakes that settle and melt on the palimpsest before me. December cold seeps from the stones of the scriptorium, and I can write only a few words here or a short phrase there before I must warm my hands in my cassock. A fire would be wasteful, and would surely draw attention and I risk enough by writing this. Yet I must leave this place soon, and it is probable that I will lack access to the tools and the time for writing for some long while. Auxerre, this place of my exile, has never been home and although I cannot return to my native Orléans, nor can I stay here. The truth must be known and I have written enough lies in this place, beginning with lies about myself and ending with lies about God.


Perhaps it is December that leaves me feeling this way, for it was in this month a decade ago that I abandoned truth to save my skin, the truth that others pursued to their graves. Once there was not a day that passed without the memory of shame, but like all scars it faded with time, until I seldom thought of those I betrayed. But Etienne and Lisois and all of the other ten have come to the forefront of my memory recently. It may be the late visitor from the East and his fanciful talk of Manichaeans. It would be fitting if this were so. We, too, have been accused of being Manichaeans, by a monk in Limoges who knows only his own fantasies and the lies I myself spread about us. And using the recollections of Simeon I have crafted one final piece of misdirection. I hope that, wherever they are, my friends are smiling as I convince the deluded fools who persecuted us to chase phantoms.


I remember the last time I saw Etienne, his beautiful face marred by the pit where his eye had been an hour before, facing the flames with complete calm. There were fourteen of us, shown the place of our execution just beyond the city walls, the jeering mob that had pelted us with dirt and shit waiting for the spectacle of our immolation. They had cheered when Queen Constance had had Etienne pinned by the soldiers and had struck out his left eye with her staff. Etienne, who had been her trusted advisor and confessor, the most pious man, was now a political liability, a traitor for endangering the king’s plans and like all traitors sentenced to die. Yet his love of God carried him through the crisis and, when called upon to recant or to burn, he chose the fire willingly and entered wordlessly into the holocaust, offering himself as a sacrifice.


The others followed without hesitation, beginning with Etienne’s beloved friend Lisois, who ran into the flames headlong. They had been closer than brothers, raised together from childhood in the love of the Church and educated in divine wisdom by the clerics at the Church of the Holy Cross. Though in their aspect they could not have been more different—for Lisois was dark where Etienne was fair, Etienne was patient and otherworldly while Lisois was rash and very much of this world; both were fearless and endless in their love for God—it was as though they were twins born of different mothers. Before rushing to his death, Lisois cursed the assembled masses, singling out his former patron, King Robert, for special scorn. Others ranged somewhere between the equanimity of Etienne and the enthusiasm of Lisois, but each submitted to the purgation that awaited.


Not me. The heat of the flames caused me to swoon and I was overwhelmed by the smell of burning flesh. The screams of my fellow, however brief, rang in my ears. I did not feel God’s love in that moment. In my cowardice, when I was offered a chance to repent, even with the noble examples before me, I seized the chance offered me. I cried out that yes, yes, I was guilty of heresy. Their spy, I stated, had learned only a little of our practice, of our false and malicious denial of the holy Trinity and of the sacraments and of the Eternal Church. All of the things they had accused us of I admitted, and I proffered the promise of more. Our practices, I lied, were not only followed here in the city of Orléans, but throughout the king’s land and far abroad. Spare me, I pled, and lead me back into the divine light and love of God the Father, of Jesus Christ his Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Allow me the opportunity to face my creator with a clean soul, that I might not face the temporal torment of the fire and the eternal torments of Hell. God damn me for it. The king, in his magnanimity, ordered me spared and sequestered. I shall always love him for his mercy. God damn him, too.

19 January 2009

HGSA Paper Proposal

Since I am in the final process of editing a paper for our student conference at NC State, I thought I would post the original proposal. The paper will more or less follow this plan.

Proposal for "The Adoptionism of Felix and the Beginnings of 'Medieval' Heresy" a paper to be presented at the North Carolina State University History Graduate Student's Association Conference 21 February 2009.

The traditional historiography of "medieval" heresy starts the story around the turn of the millennium. As the story goes, several events marked the return of "popular" heresy to the West after a break of some 600 years. Scan mention is given to the controversies of the eighth and ninth centuries; these are typically dismissed as "intramural" affairs, lacking any significance beyond the cloister.

Yet the Adoptionist controversy that arose in Spain of the late eighth century appears to run counter to this. Felix, the bishop of Urgel, argued that Jesus Christ, as the second person of the Trinity, was adoptive in his humanity, but not in his divinity. This position smelled to the authorities like a recrudescence of the Nestorian heresy, and as such this position was attacked at three councils. Historians have followed the lead of the churchmen, often categorizing this heresy among those that plagued the Late Antique church.


These councils, and the volume of material written against Felix and Elipandus of Toledo, argue that this was no small matter. Add to this the claim of Alcuin of York that some 20,000 people had accepted Felix's position, and this controversy seems less intramural and more international. In this paper, I argue that this event needs to be properly considered with later medieval heresy. The response to it, while not as lethal as it would be in the eleventh century, is that of a government in the process of formation and its lessons would not be lost in subsequent years.

12 January 2009

Conference Biography

I was required to write a one-paragraph biographical note for an upcoming conference. Here it is.

Michael G. Bazemore, Jr. hails from Newport News, Virginia, where a love of history was imparted to him by his father on frequent visits to the nearby battlefields at Yorktown. After earning his Bachelor’s degree in 1993, not in History but in Philosophy, and following a 15-year stint trying out various careers, Mike at last returned to the study of History in the graduate program at North Carolina State. Specializing in Medieval Europe of the eleventh century, Mike is currently working on his Master’s thesis, tentatively titled The Uses of Heresy: Perspectives on Dissent in Eleventh-Century France as well as a paper for the 2009 International Medieval Conference at Leeds titled “Beware Greeks Bearing News: The Influence of Orthodox Monks on the Reporting of Heresy in Western Europe.” Following completion of his Master’s degree this spring, Mike hopes to continue his studies in the Doctoral program at Duke University or the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, where he will continue to mine the rich vein of European religiosity in the High Middle Ages.

"A Day and a Night and a Day" by Glen Duncan

Having read one of Glen Duncan's earlier efforts, the charming if uneven "I, Lucifer," I felt justified in taking a chance on his newest book "A Day and a Night and a Day." Let's start with the most important thing- Duncan can flat-out write. His narrative jerks the reader around as he spools out information in much the same fashion as his protagonist, Augustus Rose. It is a wholly remarkable work.

Rose is an American, part of a shadowy network of what are best described as "vigilante terrorists" who has, for personal reasons, spent years infiltrating a group of Muslim extremists in Spain in the wake of a terrorist bombing in Barcelona. But this is not a thriller. Rose's involvement in this organization is merely the device to set up the key relationships in the book: between him and the love of his life, Selina; and between him and a man called Harper. Harper is another American, in the employ of the government, whose job it is to get information from Rose about the organization by whatever means.

This is not a story about Rose's torment, although it is. Nor is it a misplaced cri de coeur against torture. Indeed, Duncan seems to understand that, as Harper puts it, we always choose our atrocities. This is about the peculiar relationship that springs up between a torturer and his victim, about the places the victim goes to escape the pain, and about what is left to a victim who by a fluke survives and must continue with the knowledge of what he has endured.

Fiction works best when it is truer than nonfiction. For the few fantastic elements of this book, it works because it is more real somehow than news coverage of torture. There are amazing insights into the forces that motivate extremists of all stripes. "A Day and a Night and a Day" is as powerful a statement about the consequences of human action , and as strong an indictment of man's cruelty to man, as you are likely to read.

11 January 2009

"Gran Torino" and "The Shootist"

WARNING: SPOILERS AHEAD I'll be as vague as possible, but they're there.

I originally conceived of this post as a review of the Clint Eastwood film "Gran Torino," a film my wife and I saw not so much as a result of the commercials or of the numerous award nominations it received as for the fact that I enjoyed reading the script one day when I was avoiding the work of writing papers. However, the film has been reviewed widely, and I am no professional film critic. What I can say is that I feel it is an extremely well-made film with a strong script and an excellent cast that tells a not altogether new story.

This was brought home to me in the third act, as Walter Kowalski (Eastwood) is preparing for the climatic confrontation with the Hmong gangbangers who are menacing the Hmong teenagers, Thao and Sue, the crusty Kowalski has taken under his wing. He gets a haircut and a shave. He is fitted for a suit. My wife whispered to me "It's like 'The Shootist.'" As usual she is right.

For those of you who have not seen this masterpiece, "The Shootist" was John Wayne's last film. In it, Wayne portrayed J.B.Books, famed gunfighter, who has come to Carson City, Nevada in 1901 to die of cancer. It also starred Jimmy Stewart, Lauren Bacall, Harry Morgan and Ron Howard among other notables. The parallels are intersting.

Books is dying of cancer (like the man portraying him), as is Kowalski, though the latter's predicament is hinted at instead of being stated explicitly. Both are men whose lives have been marked and marred by violence: Books, as mentioned earlier, is a renowned gunslinger; Kowalski is scarred by his service in the Korean War. And in the end, both make a final, heroic sacrifice to rescue a young person who seems determined to follow in the footsteps of the older man.

In both of these movies, it is as though the characters these fine Western actors portrayed have come home to roost. This is made apparent in "The Shootist" as the narration of Books's life at the beginning is accompanied by clips from many of Wayne's previous movies. "Gran Torino" is more subtle, but the old Eastwood characters are there. There's the laconic menace of the Man With No Name ("Dollars" trilogy), the conspicuous tobacco spitting of a loner scarred by war ("The Outlaw Josey Wales"), the aging warior who wonders about the choices he's made ("Unforgiven"), the avenging angel who protects the innocent ("Dirty Harry"), even the grizzled Marine who takes an unlikely recruit under his tutelage in order to make him a man ("Heartbreak Ridge").*

The end is, perhaps, where "Gran Torino" does "The Shootist" one better. Books, in order to save Gillom Rogers (Howard) from embracing the life of the gunslinger, faces down the three men the boy most respects for their prowess. The end is almost predicatable. Books kills all three and is gunned down by the bartender. Gillom, in turn, kills the bartender with Books's gun, realizes what he's done, and throws the gun away. Books dies at peace.**

Kowalski manages to save the Hmong boy, Thao, from learning what it is to kill someone. This time, the old gunslinger faces his enemies alone and unarmed, offering himself as a sacrifice to get the gang members out of Thao's and Sue's lives. This is the triumph of "Gran Torino." The ancient warior, who is sick and sick of killing, finds a way to defeat his enemy without killing, though at great cost. Having weighed this cost and accepted it, Kowalski finds the bargain acceptable to save the innocence of Thao. Those who have derided this film as some sort of retread of Eastwood's old characters should think again- none of them would have faced death so bravely.

* No, there is not a trace of Philoe Beddoe to be found.
** In Glendon Swathout's book there is no such happy ending. Gillom offers to shoot Books and put him out of his misery as he lays dying, an offer Books accepts. The boy then shoots Books unceremoniously.

08 January 2009

The Curious Phenomenon of Facebook "Friends"

The phenomenon of Facebook "friends," a concept I have always found somewhat dubious, has come to seem even moreso of late, thanks to the spate of members of the Warwick High School class of 1989 who have recently contacted me, among others. There is, as far as I know, nothing wrong with these people. Some of them I am genuinely happy and intrigued to hear from. It is simply the case that some of these petitions for "friendship" seem to be indicative of a relaxed meaning of the word, which may be a shame.

Since I began this with a reference to contacts from members of my high school graduating class, let me begin with high school. In the now nearly twenty years since graduating high school, I have been in regular contact with two, one of whom graduated two years before me and who is now my wife of fifteen years, the other of whom is the oldest friend I am currently in contact with. There are other old friends with whom I have had intermittent contact over the years and with whom I am still happy to have a chat and a beer.

There are a few people currently awaiting approval. These are people whose names I remember, but whom I knew, at best, tangentially. Twenty years ago. This is at the heart of the curious nature of Facebook friendship.

These are most likely fine people. But I did not know them then, and I am certainly not going to open myself up to them now. I feel on some days as though I have compromised my cherished notions of friendship with the 53 "friends" on my list. Again, these are all fine people. Nonetheless, they are not all people I would invite to a wedding, or ask for help if I were in trouble, nor would I expect this of them, and that sort of reciprocal relationship, to me, has been the defining characteristic of friendship.

Because once I get an idea I am hard-pressed to let it go and because I can be obsessive about things, I did a survey. On the day of the survey there were 53 friends on my list. Those friends had a total of 7621 friends on their lists, counting repeats.* This is an average, allowing for rounding, of 144 friends per person. Digging deeper, some interesting numbers stick out, showing the danger of averages. For instance, there are the high and low ends, 770 and three. And the median number of friends was 82, showing that there is a small group of people with a lot of friends (770, 550, 546, 417, 344 were the top five) dragging the numbers up.

I actually understand why the person with 770 friends has this number, but I am still staggered by these high-end numbers. Not because these are not good people or because I am an introvert (though to an extent I am). It is simply impossible to have more than a basic passing acquaintance with so many people.

What does all this mean? The likely answer is that, like the dollar, the basic value of friendship is slipping with inflation. Ten years ago, I could count the number of people I would call my friend on my fingers. Now there are fifty-some odd people out there with access to some details on my life who are called my friends and potentially many more through this blog. But all of the things these people have access to are things I would not be ashamed to have publicly known. I don't get the sense that such reserve is the rule.

The reason for this may lie in biology, in the fact that, as humans, we have evolved to live in small hunter-gatherer groups and that, as far as culture has moved in the last ten thousand years, biology moves more slowly. This disconnect is worth exploring, but will have to wait for another post.

In the meantime, if anyone from the Warwick High School Class of 1989 reads this and is awaiting my answer on Facebook "friendship" I'm sorry. You are no doubt a good person and it is quite possible that my life would be vastly enriched for having known you. But my dance card is pretty full at the moment, and I need to hold the line somewhere.

* Edited for truth. The post originally read "not counting repeats" which makes me seem even more obsessive than I already was.

"The Return of Martin Guerre" by Natalie Zemon Davis

This is a truly wonderful little book that shows what a talented historian can do with the historical record to reconstruct lost worlds. Martin Guerre was a Provencal peasant of Basque extraction who abandoned his wife in the middle years of the sixteenth century. Some eight years after his departure, a man claiming to be Martin Guerre appeared in his village of Artigat and resumed Martin's marriage and his business.

This man was another peasant named Arnaud du Tilh, who was fortunate enough to have heard about the desertion by Martin and to have a fairly strong resemblance to him. Doubts were initially quieted by "Matrin's" intimate knowledge of his previous life, but a property suit brought into question the identity of "Martin Guerre." The story goes through two court cases, but is really complicated when the real Martin Guerre appears.

Davis is a fantastic writer who sifts through reams and reams of Toulousain court records and correspondence to tell this story. Using the sources, she is able to paint a vivid picture of peasant life in this corner of France, and integrates the story into larger movements such as the Protestant Reformation. She successfully resists the urge to say more than her sources will allow. The people of the village of Artigat become living, breathing beings. "The Return of Martin Guerre" is a testament to what history can be and to the truth of the old saying that, indeed, truth is stranger than fiction.

02 January 2009

Dogs and Cloning

As anyone who knows me can tell you, all you have to do to get me talking non-stop is to ask me about my dogs. I have been the proud parent or co-parent of four magnificent mutts, and the happiness they bring into my life defies rational description. I have come to conclude that dogs are a part of the human condition, having been members of our extended families for, depending on the source and the method used, up to 135,000 years, with fossil finds showing humans and wolves in close proximity even longer. Even accepting the standard 10,000- 15,000-year time frame most often cited, dogs have clearly been with us for longer than civilization itself.

It is with this perspective that I read an article in the New York Times about cloning dogs in the attempt to retain beloved pets. On the one hand, I can sympathize. My oldest dog, Grendel, is approaching his ninth birthday. As a largish dog, his expected lifespan is generally put at between eight and thirteen years, and since he is healthy I have no reason to expect it to be on the short side. Grendel is a wonderful dog. He is intelligent, happy and (I daresay) handsome, a tolerant older sibling to the other dogs (ages six years and seven months), and a faithful companion. On the other hand, that I must someday lose him is a source of worry and sadness, but it is this fact that also gives our relationship poignancy. It is a reminder that I must cherish each day we share together and that I should never take his presence for granted.

Cloning holds no hope of conferring immortality on Grendel. Those who cleave to such hopes must have an overly deterministic view of life, as though genes were the only (or at least greatest) contributor to the being that is their dog, a view which, naturally, they would not extend to themselves. Even though in the NYT article the entrepreneur gives a nod to nurture, he sells this hope. That's what makes the offer of cloning so insidious; it is an offer of perpetuity that is only shown false after it is far too late for the purchaser and the animal involved.

A dog cloned from Grendel, would be just that, a dog cloned from Grendel. A wiser parent, I would not panic with his digestive woes, sparing him numerous trips to the vet that are certainly the reason for his pathological fear of the place. I might be able to mitigate the effects of a genetic tendency to hip dysplasia through different nutrition. He would grow up the youngest of the pack and not the oldest, perhaps lacking the confidence he has around other dogs. There would be no minute bare patch on his muzzle where a copperhead bit him one terrifying evening when he was four months old. The dimples at his hips, remnants of the bilateral Femoral Head Ostectomies he had eight years ago would not be there; they are a sign, certainly of pain, but also of his triumph over adversity, and ours (I teared up the first morning I saw him walk up stairs after months of bunny-hopping before and after surgery).

He would likely not even be named Grendel. I named him that because I had so recently been enthralled by the language of Seamus Heaney's verse translation of the ancient epic.

All in all, it is hard to see how such a clone would be an any way a continuation of the original, so much has he been shaped by circumstance. This new creature would likely be intelligent, energetic and very, very, black, just like his progenitor. But he wouldn't be Grendel, nor will these clones for which people are paying huge sums be the lost pets they resemble. It is a disservice, to the memory of beloved family members and to the living animals cloned from them, to expect otherwise. Better to go to the pound, find a likely, lively puppy, and adopt an animal truly in need, than to create a new one in the vain hope of capturing that which cannot be captured.

"A Mercy" by Toni Morrison

I know I am supposed to gush about the new Toni Morrison novel, as though her name and accomplishments were a sort of talisman or guarantor of excellence, but "A Mercy" left me, for the most part, cold. Her writing was solid, which one would expect of a Nobel laureate, and she performs a deft job of creating different voices for narrating the different characters. It is an interesting exploration of the different kinds of slavery that existed in late-17th-century North America. But the characters never seemed completely realized, and the big reveal at the end did not automatically follow from the rest of the story.

Morrison is obviously a talented stylist, and there are some truly good bits, with the detailed back story of the improbably named Messalina springing to mind. But "A Mercy" ultimately fails to be anything more, and in some ways a bit less, than the sum of its parts. In attempting to explore the notions of slavery in the late 1600s, she does a decent job of placing us there. But she fails to craft a compelling story from what are some very good pieces.

28 November 2008

Paper proposal for International Medieval Congress...accepted!!

A few months ago, on a lark, I sent in a paper proposal for the 2009 International Medieval Congress at Leeds. For those not in the know, this is one of the two annual huge Medieval Studies conferences held annually, the other held at the American Leeds- Kalamazoo, Michigan. While I was at 'zoo last year, I met the organizers of this year's IMC, and they told me about the leitmotif of this conference, heresy and orthodoxy, and when I told them some of my ideas, they encouraged me to submit a proposal. The paper is a spinoff of ideas I have developed while working on my Master's thesis, and I hope I can do it justice. Here it is, then, the paper that I will present on Bastille Day 2009. All that's left to do is write the damn thing...

Proposal for "Beware Greeks Bearing News: the Influence of Orthodox Monks on the Reporting of Heresy in Western Europe"

"Recent scholarship into 11th-century texts such as the "Letter of Heribert" and the sermons of Ademar of Chabannes have done much to revive the notion that the 'heretics' of 11th-century France were proselytized by Bogomil missionaries from the Byzantine Empire. They have pointed toward superficial similarities between the western 'heretics' described and the Bogomils, and toward the language used in polemics against the new religious movements as evidence of their connection. I intend to propose that these similarities cannot be taken as prima facie evidence of a connection. They may, rather, constitute evidence of a different kind of influence - that of visiting Orthodox monks on the chronicling of reformist movements by their Catholic brethren."

24 November 2008

Happy Anniversary, Mr. Darwin

Today is the 149th anniversary of the publication of "The Origin of Species," one of the most important books ever published and containing certainly the supreme scientific insight of the last two hundred years. Even those few who will read this who are creationists have benefited from the consequences of Darwin's insight in ways large and small.

It is an amazing book, and one I highly recommend. Darwin builds his case logically beginning with the familiar forms of artificial selection used by farmers and breeders, and moving to the vast sweep of life on Earth. He begins hesitantly, laying out his ideas cautiously. As his case builds, he becomes more and more confident, and the accumulated weight of evidence in his argument gives it unstoppable momentum. There are individual things he gets wrong, but on the one big idea he is absolutely right. And by the end, you can tell that he knows it.

The single best encomium to Darwin and the theory evolution by means of natural selection that I have ever read was written by Ian McEwan, a writer whom I both love and loathe. I love him, because he is possibly the finest living writer working in the English language; I loathe him because he's so much better a writer than I can probably hope to be. This is from his 2005 novel "Saturday."

"What better creation myth? An unimaginable sweep of time, numberless generations spawning by infinitesimal steps complex living beauty out of inert matter, driven on by the blind furies of random mutation, natural selection and environmental change, with the tragedy of forms continually dying, and lately the wonder of minds emerging and with them morality, love, art, cities-- and the unprecedented bonus of being demonstrably true."

Don't let the talk of myths fool you; this is how it happens. It is no less beautiful than any other idea that has been proposed and fills me with the sense of awe that religion never gave me. And don't get hung up on the word "theory" either. There are those out there who would have you believe it means the same thing as "conjecture." In the sciences, it does not. It means a hypothesis that is so supported by data and experiment that it is accepted as true. One reliably reproducible counter-instance sends the whole edifice tumbling down. Keep waiting...

Into the Deep Water- Take Two

OK, let's try this again. When I originally set this blog up, my intention was simply to write. However, my old friend inertia (and his buddies laziness and ennui) popped up and I dropped the blog pretty quickly. So, I'll try again. No promises about frequency, but let's see what happens.